• Naturopathy
    • Workplace Wellness
  • Mentoring
    • Learn
    • Practitioner retreat
  • About
    • About Gill
    • Naturopathy FAQ
    • Media
    • Speaking
  • Articles
  • Newsletter
  • Recipes & Resources
    • Food
    • Books
    • Vodcasts & more
  • Contact
facebook
rss
twitter

Articles

08
AUG
2014

Does the Fast Diet live up to the hype?

Tags : anorexia, fad diets, Fast Diet, fasting, health coaching, horizon documentary, longevity, Mosley
Posted By : Gill Stannard
Comments : 2

As a naturopath and health coach I cringe every time a diet book hits the headlines. One day there’s one spruiking a low carbohydrate diet, the next it’s high protein, no fat or high fat.

In the past year Dr Michael Mosley’s Fast Diet, also known as the 5:2 diet, attracted a lot of attention. As so many credible professionals have endorsed it, I thought I’d take a closer look. So how does it rate?

What’s it all about?

This is essentially a weight loss program, borrowing the psedoscience of the intermittent fasting regime. There is a belief that if you eat significantly less than the average daily recommended kilojoules you will live longer. With the intermittent fasting-based Fast Diet, instead of eating less every day the week is broken into two severely food restricted days (2400 kilojoules /600 calories) and five days when you can eat and drink anything you wish.

Intermittent fasting is not a novel concept – animal studies on it begun in 1945. Nor is the 5:2 model new. MD Bert Herring published The Fast 5 diet in 2005, describing it as “one approach to a weight-reduction dieting”.

Whose spruiking it?

Mosely is a psychiatrist turned television producer/presenter who set himself up as a guinea pig following the 5:2 diet for the sake of an Horizon documentary. His co-author Mimi Spencer, a fashion journalist. Neither have had any significant  nutritional training.

The claims

Mosley has claimed intermittent fasting has the following benefits:

  1. As well as offering a fresh approach for people trying to lose weight, intermittent fasting has been developed by scientists wanting to help people reduce their risk of developing diabetes, dementia and cancer.
  2. The concept has been most extensively studied in volunteers who are obese or overweight. In a recent study of 115 overweight women, those who restricted their calories two days a week lost more fat and had a greater improvement in biomarkers related to breast cancer risk than women who were conventionally daily dieting.
  3. The benefits in people who are not overweight are less clear because there have been fewer studies. In one experiment, a number of fit young men were asked to practice intermittent fasting without losing weight for a few weeks. During that time they saw improved insulin sensitivity, a marker for reduced diabetes risk.
  4. Animal studies have shown that intermittent fasting reduces risk of dementia. Human studies have just begun.
  5. Fasting also has a spiritual dimension and has been advocated by most of the great religions

Source: Fast Diet FAQ

Demystifying the claims

In an era of evidence-based medicine, health claims framed in fuzzy language tends to trigger alarm bells

Looking at the claims:

  • The first point doesn’t actually claim that the diet reduces the risk of dementia, diabetes and cancer. Rather it’s devised by scientists “wanting to help people” reduce those risks.
  • The second, omits the fact that obese women are at greater risk of breast cancer and that any significant weight loss, regardless of regime, will reduce those markers. Furthermore there are no studies that can demonstrate that intermittent fasting lowers a woman’s risk of developing breast cancer.
  • The third point at least admits there’s a paucity of hard evidence that people of average weight have any prolonged health benefits from intermittent fasting. Also testing for diabetes markers in non-diabetics is irrelevant and doesn’t necessarily correlate with those who have the disease.
  • The fourth point alludes to a mouse study, showing reduced calorie intake delayed the onset of dementia in mice that are bred to develop the condition. There is no evidence of this being replicated in humans with or without the gene
  • And lastly, is religion the best endorsement for a diet? Are they promoting the Fast Diet as a spiritual practice, for weight loss, health prevention or longevity?

Concerns

“Every fool can fast, but only the wise man knows how to break a fast.”

G.B. Shaw

What you eat, rather than just the total kilojoules, needs more scrutiny. Three foods that reoccur in almost every suggested 5:2 diet plan are eggs, bacon and smoked salmon. The first two are high in saturated fat (the nutritional jury can’t agree on whether this is a good or bad thing). Bacon, with or without the fat trimmed, is a low in good nutrition and high in salt and potentially cancer-causing nitrosamines. Almost all smoked salmon in Australia is from farmed salmon which has a different (and vastly inferior) fat profile to wild.

It might encourage binging

It could encourage participants to see the non-restricted intake days as a free pass for five days, when good nutrition goes out the window. This may lead to some less-than-healthy binging. As an experienced health practitioner, I’m skeptical about the foods some people choose to compensate for the fasting days.

Are you using the diet to live longer or for weight loss?

The majority of  questions I’ve had about the diet have been from women, under (or just on) normal weight, with a history of dieting and over-exercising.  To date, no one has asked about longevity or healthy living in relation to following the plan. This suggests, whatever the intentions, it’s perceived by the public as another diet book, rather than a health plan. Undertaken from this paradigm, the 5:2 is just another guise for a binge/starve cycle, punishing to self-esteem and never an effective strategy for long term weightloss.

Adapting the Fast Diet: a healthier option

Rather than focusing on the energy count two days a week, how about having a day of raw or steamed plant-based food each week? Then for the other six days be conscious of serving sizes and follow more of a ‘points’ approach – looking for a balance of lean good quality protein, true wholegrains, masses of vegetables, some fruit and only a little added sugar and animal fat.

In most cases weight-loss comes down to tweaking the ratio of energy in (what you eat) with energy out (how you move your body). Any diet that results in burning more fuel than you consume should lead to weight reduction. On that basis, the 5:2 diet should work as a weight loss plan, depending on the food choices you make on the five non-fasting days and if you continue to exercise.

But is this intermittent fasting the healthiest way to loose and maintain weight? My nutritional training questions the counter-intuitive nature of potentially consuming unrestricted animal products and not changing unhealthy eating (and drinking) patterns.

Always bear in mind it’s not just the number of kilojoules you consume but the quality of the food it’s in that impacts your health and longevity.

The Fast Diet: The Secret of Intermittent Fasting  -  Lose Weight, Stay Healthy, Live LongerConsider a therapeutic fast rather than a ‘diet’

A ‘fast’ traditionally means going without food for a period of time, consuming only water or medicinal liquids instead. The idea is to give your digestive system some time out for recuperation and repair.

But fasting was always done in conjunction with other therapies, usually massage, hypdrotherapy and physical rest. It was never solely about not eating. It’s rare to find someone who wants to spend their holiday taking on such a regime.

Another option is a modified fast, or as I call it ‘spring cleaning’. You can read more about it here.

bookcover-final-widget-1

Similar Posts:

  • diet and cancer risks
  • Can a crash diet cure type 2 diabetes?
  • The Climate Change Diet: better health for you and the planet
  • “Now with 50% less fat”: the truth behind nutritional claims
  • If you’re fat, you’re sick?

About the Author
Gill Stannard is one of Australia's most experienced naturopaths and mentors, now in her third decade of service to the healing profession. You can work with Gill in person in Sydney (and every couple of months in Melbourne), or from anywhere in the world via Skype. What's stopping you from living a healthier and happier life? Contact coaching@gillstannard.com.au for more details, or book you consultation at http://bookeo.com/gillstannard Gill has written hundreds of articles on this site, just use the search box to find more . Like my facebook page https://www.facebook.com/citynaturaltherapies

Social Share

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: Gill Stannard » Health Q & A – fasting

  2. Pingback: Gill Stannard » Can a crash diet cure type 2 diabetes?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

captcha *

Receive Gill’s Newsletter FREE

Work With Gill

Gill Stannard Work With Gill

Recent Posts

Holiday hours and clinic update

December 10, 2019

Recipe: festive chocolate bark

December 06, 2019

November clinic update

November 25, 2019

Book review: Create a Fertile Life

November 11, 2019

Archives

  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007
  • February 2007
  • January 2007
  • December 2006
  • November 2006
  • October 2006
  • September 2006
  • August 2006
  • July 2006
  • June 2006
  • May 2006
  • April 2006
  • February 2006
  • January 2006
  • December 2005
  • November 2005
  • October 2005
  • Clinic updates: gift vouchers, last minute consults and recipes (to keep the people with the most challenging dieta… https://t.co/lZvV0P4f2r 7 hours ago
  • @netregistry issues continue. Still can’t load new content to my website. Apologies to subscribers for a very slim newsletter this month! yesterday
  • Friends don’t let friend’s drink water with ‘just a drop’ of essential oil. Really. This is strong medicine, often… https://t.co/X5NKTQlKiR 3 days ago
  • @Dunc21157848 @netregistry After you denying my website issues were not your fault I’ve spent $$ with my website gu… https://t.co/XPaOTz2BY5 6 days ago
  • “This year 90 volunteers have delivered 26 Survivors Teaching Students presentations across Australia and reached j… https://t.co/TQ6oJI8JRd 8 days ago
facebook Facebook
twitter Twitter
rss Feed Reader
© 2019 Gill Stannard Naturopath | Mentor